Skip to main content

Grateful Dead Live at Madison Square Garden on 1990-09-18

Audio Preview

Grateful Dead Live at Madison Square Garden on 1990-09-18

Topics Live concert

Mississippi Half Step, Minglewood Blues, Loser, Picasso Moon, Row Jimmy, Desolation Row, To Lay Me Down, Promised Land Eyes Of The World-> Estimated Prophet-> Foolish Heart-> Drums-> Jam-> The Other One-> The Wheel-> Sugar Magnolia, E: Knockin' On Heaven's Door

Collection GratefulDead
Band/Artist Grateful Dead
Venue Madison Square Garden
Location New York, NY

Source SBD>Cm>Dat>CD>WAV>SHN


Lineage: SBD->Cm->Dat->CD->Cool Edit Pro->CD via Charlie Miller


Reviewer: KGuide - favoritefavoritefavoritefavorite - February 26, 2017
Subject: My first show
This was my first show.

Minglewood is awesome, some great Jerry & Bruce moments.

Picasso Moon is the best ever played.

To Lay Me Down is special.

Promise Land is intense. This was the first and last time I saw Jerry dance in person. He stopped his feet and banged his head.
Reviewer: johnbrosnan - favoritefavoritefavoritefavorite - November 12, 2016
Subject: Eyes
Eyes is incredible here. I'm guessing that's hornsby
Reviewer: JamsOnly - favoritefavoritefavorite - November 18, 2012
Subject: 9/18/90
Highlights: To Lay Me Down, Foolish Heart
Reviewer: Mind Wondrin - favoritefavoritefavorite - November 9, 2012
Subject: MSG 4th of 6. 1990
Tough spots and flashes of brilliance in the middle of a run that got better each day. This was during the dualing-keys era when Vince was new and Hornsby was slumming it alongside (in his 3rd show as a touring member). But this date is particularly heavy on the Vince (handed the reins throughout). Aside from that this is a Phil show - he goes nuts. />
1st Set. C+, a little above average. The 3 great moments are Minglewood (energized by Hornsby the band is suddenly warmed up); Row Jimmy (One of '90s' best; at a faster pace, Vince dominates and this influences Jer); and Promised Land (one the best of the year because there's great Bruce, Phil goes crazy, and with extra band members it takes longer for everyone to get theirs in). Though part of this show was released as Road Trips 2-1, the 1st set highlights are frustratingly missing from that release!

2nd set. C+. Not the best Set-2 from this run but worth a listen.
Highlights: Drums through Sugar
In an era where sets were all over the place, consistency-wise, this set stands out for a good 5-song section. Drums is one of the best of '90 with Bill starting-out with a late-60s sound. The last half of Other One is spot-on with a full-stop on the Wheel segue. After a concise version of that song Hornsby revs a unique Sugar Mag away from Bobby and hands it to Jer. />
The 2nd set is probably best known for a sorta-unique Jam Out of Foolish Heart. It's arguably an era-relevant jam and received its classic-status-nod by reason of inclusion in the So Many Roads box set, albeit in edited form. It's restored to full length on Road Trips 2-1 and though it's much better in that context and length, it's still not really a show highlight as much as an historical tick-list bauble. The 1st half of the 2nd set is pretty shaky but interesting to those examining Vince's development (especially on Eyes where he heavily stylizes and the guys are perplexed enough to roll it out to an 18-minute palate-cleanser) and because Phil was in a total hyperdrive
mood. />
Hornsby had the accordion out for
encore. />
Road Trips 2-2 is not the best source for this show. Matrix lovers should look for a great hansokolow (not on the archive?). The Miller/Tetzeli copies have been EQ'd to misery. The Miller-12885 is the pick    -mostly beating out Road Trips-   and has smother trannies than the otherwise equivalent Richey-11811 (which has the best presence but more noticeable hum in the 1st set).

An average show but with some era-interest points :
3 stars

Row Jimmy
Promised Land (for the great Bruce/Phil ending)
Drums>Space> Other One>Wheel>Sugar Mag

Geez, a 6-day run at MSG. W 31st/Penn Station musta seemed a bit w~e~i~r~d for a week.
Reviewer: Longshank13 - favoritefavoritefavoritefavorite - July 22, 2012
Subject: Brent Memorial ?
Really good show, amazing, wonderful sound quality, Have to agree with other reviewers ....sure sounds like a matrix. Couldn’t figure it out till I saw at the end of the reviews, “Via Charlie Miller,”....Usually a good thing. Have to agree with the reviews concerning Minglewood, Row Jimmy and Promised Land....better than average... And oh yea...” Best Picasso Moon Ever,” Don't usually go for the best ever stuff...but in this case....I might have to. Jam out of Foolish Heart very interesting, as one review stated, “Era-relevant jam,” would be appropriate. Actually the whole show I would call very representative of the best of the 90's Dead, a little light on the Jerry, heavy on the other stuff, like 2 keyboards...Like Phil all over the place,( In a really, really good way)....Like Bruce on the accordion on Knockin' on Heavens Door. A really good 90's show cause the Jerry that's there is as powerful as ever. Don't of course know if it really was a Brent memorial show, but if it was they did it up good... The To Lay Me Down, And Knockin' On Heavens Door are obvious and deeply stirring...but what about Foolish Heart? Brent was by all accounts; insecure, afraid of love, and had no clue as to how many deeply loved him, and would have done anything to help him....Does that qualify as a “Foolish Heart?” And oh yea...Eyes starts out sorta slow and well...boring....and before I realizing it, it turns into this amazing piece of improvisation....Funny how the Dead can do that. Thanks for reading my review.
Reviewer: orygunjim - favoritefavoritefavoritefavorite - June 15, 2009
Subject: Foolish Jam
Good enough to be used on the SMR box set. Not that it's a definitive representation of all dead music, but this is a definitive jam of that era. I dig the OtherOne tease in this jam that resolves after drums/space with a pretty satisfying version. The whole band gets quiet and let's Phil blow the doors open at 01:26 or so (stream timer), then Dan Healy takes a dump on Bob's vocals...that's the kind of sh*t that could get a guy fired. Oh right, it did.
Reviewer: seamones1 - favoritefavoritefavoritefavorite - May 8, 2009
Subject: Best post Brent first set
Update: Ok, so 9-10-91 IS the best post brent first set. But this one does not start off slowly. Nothing to complain about the Halfstep, although nothing to particularly rave about. Minglewoods are perhaps a dime a dozen, but this one rocks. As i said earlier best Picasso Moon, best To Lay Me Down; top 3 Promised Land's.

There I said it. Best ever Picasso Moon. Amazing To Lay Me Down. There is even something special about Promised. The Foolish Heart Jam is unique and fantastic.
Reviewer: dont blow my high - favoritefavoritefavoritefavorite - December 11, 2008
Subject: Great Sound!
Some really great tracks on this one, Hornsby is definitely the real deal. You can hear him quote Keith Jarret's famous "Koln Concert" in the beginning of the jam after Foolish Heart, fantastic.
Reviewer: JamminJerome - favoritefavoritefavoritefavorite - April 22, 2008
Subject: Starts off weak but ends strong
This run is a very strong one, and perhaps the strongest post-Brent. The setlist here is a lot of fun, with a lot of surprises, as was the norm for the 90s. The first set is a little rusty - Jerry's playing well but the singing is pretty poor and the band seems to be a bit out of sync. They pull everything together for a fantastic To Lay Me Down - one of the best of the post 1980 versions - and get ready for the second set. The second set is very good. Energy is high and things seem to gel a lot more. The eyes>estimated>foolish>jam is a very tasty treat, and the Sugar Magnolia does not disappoint. The sound here is strong and well-balanced, and at times sounds like a Matrix.
1st set = 2.5 stars
2nd set = 4.5 stars
Sound = 5 stars
overall = 4 stars
Reviewer: Vince Holly - favoritefavoritefavoritefavoritefavorite - August 27, 2006
Subject: To lay me down
This was a beautiful tribute to Brent. Jerry laid it out for our dear brother, who went to an early rest. I sought out this song, because my dear friend died this past week and I wanted to pay him tribute. As I listened to the band play this heartfelt version, I felt how much a wonderful friend impacts your life. Live on Brent... and Steve!
Reviewer: sperry - favoritefavoritefavoritefavorite - July 9, 2006
Subject: under estimated
I stumbled unto this show about a year after it was played. Definely lost in the MSG mix with 9-20-90 etc. etc. But listen to it, it is sweet and the boys are oh so tight, with hornsby blastin through the such standards as 1/2 step,minglewood, lay me down, eyes etc. etc.
check it out you won't be let down.

Four stars, no show is ever perfect...that's what makes it so perfect.

Reviewer: lmnop999 - favorite - April 9, 2006
Subject: Where do I click to stream
Where do I click to stream ? ?
I thought that this stuff was available for streaming and yet the only options seem to be "batting average" and "help with downloads". Am I missing something? (other than the spectacular music)
Reviewer: lobster12 - favoritefavoritefavoritefavorite - January 26, 2006
Subject: where's bruce?
BH is all over the place for the entire run except here. Strange. Great show though. Obviously gets lost in the shuffle from the othe nights, but i love the Eyes>estimated>foolish placement.

Revise: Played this on better speakers and I'm getting Hornsby. Also of note, an amazing post Foolish jam before drums. have had that on a loop for a week.
Reviewer: dmilks - favoritefavoritefavoritefavorite - December 14, 2005
Subject: 9-18-90
Another awesome sounding MSG 90 show. 4+ stars.

Sure sounds like a matrix mix to me..??..

To Lobster12, I am hearing lots of Hornsby on this night. He takes solos on 1/2 Step & Minglewood. 3:45 into Minglewood he has the crowd in the palm of his hand.
Reviewer: bomberholds - favoritefavoritefavoritefavoritefavorite - March 9, 2005
Subject: what a run
the entire run at the garden was amazing. the band clearly steps up after brent's passing. 90-91 were such great years for the band musically and these 6 shows were some of the best. it is so great to hear these again. thank you archive.
Reviewer: Trannyman - favoritefavoritefavoritefavorite - January 20, 2005
Subject: Sleeper show
This show gets the least pub of the MSG run, but is full of extended jamming and treats. Eyes runs near 20 min here, and it is the superior Other One of the two played at MSG. Foolish Heart is also played in a lengthy, experimental version. Like all of the 90 MSG run, the band is relaxed and aiming to explore new territory.
Reviewer: redbones - favoritefavoritefavoritefavorite - August 9, 2004
Subject: Get This One
This whole show is pretty solid - very nice Eyes > Foolish Heart. To Lay Me Down, though, is the real reason to get it. Very powerful stuff. As I write this review, it is the 9th anniversary of Jerry's passing into the cosmos. I am listening to To Lay Me Down and thinking of the old man - still missing him.
Reviewer: fez_43 - favoritefavoritefavoritefavorite - May 9, 2004
Subject: some comments
I have always cherished this show due to the upbeat version of foolish heart. the recording is good, little hiss present but the levels are a little muddy, especially during 'eyes'. hornsby seems to be turned down in the mix as not to hurt vince's feelings. ;)
Reviewer: shmev - favoritefavoritefavoritefavorite - April 27, 2004
Subject: rip brent
first of the 3 shows i saw at msg.....some how it seemed like a farwell to brent show....first to lay me down since he passed....very heartfelt and emotional singing by jerry....promised land to close.....knocking on heavens door pretty muched capped the evening....great quality....9/20/90 was the best of the 3 nights, but there where moments during this show that made me weep and jump for joy at the same time...funny how the dead always had that effect on people.....peace shmev
info Stream Only
Stream playlist
( VBR )
In Collection
Grateful Dead
In Collection
Live Music Archive
Uploaded by
Jonathan Aizen
on 4/3/2004
SIMILAR ITEMS (based on metadata)
Grateful Dead
by Grateful Dead
eye 13,836
favorite 17
comment 14
favoritefavoritefavoritefavorite ( 14 reviews )
Source: Analog SBD>DAT>CDR>WAV>SHN
Grateful Dead
by Grateful Dead
eye 20,017
favorite 13
comment 18
favoritefavoritefavoritefavorite ( 18 reviews )
Source: Analog SBD>DAT>CDR>WAV>SHN
Grateful Dead
by Grateful Dead
eye 3,985
favorite 3
comment 0
Source: Soundboard patched with Audience
Grateful Dead
by Grateful Dead
eye 11,959
favorite 9
comment 3
favoritefavoritefavoritefavorite ( 3 reviews )
Source: Soundboard patched with Audience
Grateful Dead
by Grateful Dead
eye 7,540
favorite 5
comment 3
favoritefavoritefavoritefavorite ( 3 reviews )
Source: SBD > DAT > CDR > .shn
Grateful Dead
by Grateful Dead
eye 38,956
favorite 64
comment 47
favoritefavoritefavoritefavoritefavorite ( 47 reviews )
Source: MattMan remaster of shnid=10536
Grateful Dead
by Grateful Dead
eye 20,340
favorite 22
comment 10
favoritefavoritefavoritefavorite ( 10 reviews )
Source: Hartford Civic Center SBD feed to HCN studios via ISDN > HCN Master Reel > DAT(Sony ES)recorded/(Tascam DA20mkII) playback>Pioneer PDR 555>CDR>WAV>SHN
Grateful Dead
by Grateful Dead
eye 5,556
favorite 9
comment 7
favoritefavoritefavoritefavorite ( 7 reviews )
Grateful Dead
by Grateful Dead
eye 5,143
favorite 1
comment 1
favoritefavoritefavorite ( 1 reviews )
Source: Audience: Schoeps mk21's
Grateful Dead
by Grateful Dead
eye 20,953
favorite 21
comment 20
favoritefavoritefavoritefavorite ( 20 reviews )
Source: MAD> D> CD>WAV>SHN